Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Television (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=110)
-   -   Amazon : Star Trek: Picard (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33707686)

Pierre 21-04-2021 21:26

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
I suppose we’ll have to casually forget that he’s actually an android now.

Chris 21-04-2021 21:29

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
I doubt it - that gives the storytellers access to oodles of potential plot lines discussing the essence of humanity, which is the very currency Star Trek has always traded in.

General Maximus 17-06-2021 22:45

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
A trailer for season 2 has been released. Ironically the only decent copy I can find (and can't embed) is on the StarTrek.com website so you'll have to follow the link below:

https://intl.startrek.com/videos/wat...n-2-first-look

Jaymoss 17-06-2021 22:54

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
does not like my adblocker.

Paul 17-06-2021 22:58

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

This video is unavailable because we were unable to load a message from our sponsors.

If you are using ad-blocking software, please disable it and reload the page.
Yeah, they can frack off.

Not sure if this is the same thing

https://www.digitalspy.com/tv/ustv/a...ailer-villain/

General Maximus 17-06-2021 23:03

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36083734)
Not sure if this is the same thing

it is :tu:

General Maximus 13-07-2021 12:22

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Patrick Stewart is 81 today. I wish we could turn back time.

Chris 13-07-2021 12:29

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
If I could find a way …

Jaymoss 13-07-2021 12:38

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36086122)
If I could find a way …

I am so disgusted in myself for actually getting this reference !! hehe

Chris 13-07-2021 12:47

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36086126)
I am so disgusted in myself for actually getting this reference !! hehe

Earworm :devsmoke:

General Maximus 09-09-2021 08:43

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
It has been renewed for a 3rd season




Chris 09-09-2021 08:52

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
I should hope so too.

Loving that trailer though - its themes are all unashamedly ST:TNG.

With a little VOY to keep Boimler happy :D

General Maximus 09-09-2021 18:46

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
I am hoping that that is just a teaser and they'll release another one closer to the premiere date. I am not too keen on the new cast and that trailer was too generic for me and didn't feel Treky enough. I want a special moment to be teased between Picard and Guinan like we had with Picard and Riker in season 1.

Paul 09-09-2021 18:50

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
This has been known for a long time.

Quote:

The series received an informal third season green-light by January 2020 to allow the second and third seasons to be developed together and filmed back-to-back.
Production on scenes for the third season began during filming of the second, by April 2021

General Maximus 09-09-2021 18:54

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
I thought it sounded familiar and couldn't remember whether it has officially been renewed or just whether I expected it to be.

Paul 09-09-2021 19:11

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
From the trailer, Season 2 looks awsome. :D

---------- Post added at 19:11 ---------- Previous post was at 19:05 ----------

If Discovery runs to 13 episodes again, it will finish on 10 Feb 2022, meaning its highly likely Picard will follow on from it, starting on the 17th Feb 2022.

Chris 09-09-2021 20:05

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by General Maximus (Post 36092544)
I am hoping that that is just a teaser and they'll release another one closer to the premiere date. I am not too keen on the new cast and that trailer was too generic for me and didn't feel Treky enough. I want a special moment to be teased between Picard and Guinan like we had with Picard and Riker in season 1.

Are you kidding?

Q messing up the timeline forcing the Captain du jour to time-travel in order to fix it is about as Trekky as it gets.

Realism factor 10, Mr Sulu …

General Maximus 09-09-2021 20:35

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
I liked that bit and it felt perfect, the rest of it didn't. I just don't like the new cast. If it was Q, Picard, Guinan and the original cast then it would be perfect.

Chris 09-09-2021 20:39

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Guinan’s appearance in the new series is assured. They can’t just shoehorn everyone in at once though, otherwise it starts looking like a benefit concert rather than a continuation of the story.

General Maximus 09-09-2021 20:51

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
I know but rather than brining the crew back together I am under the impression they are rotating them in and out and the new cast is the main cast. I don't think we are seeing Riker and Troi again this season. Afaik it is just Guinan this season, which fits perfectly with time travel, and next season it is Worf. I hope they bring Geordie back as well.

Stephen 09-09-2021 20:56

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Picardy IS the main character. Anyone else is just a side character who may or may not stick around for long .

cimt 09-09-2021 22:33

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
I don't wanna see all these TNG characters. It has been 20 years, they would of moved on from the Enterprise and are doing their own thing.

Paul 10-09-2021 05:01

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
None of them are on the Enterprise, and all were/are "doing their own thing".

The story brings them together, at various points, in a totally believable way.

Pierre 10-09-2021 10:02

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Picard does ST IV - Voyage Home. Why not.

SnoopZ 18-01-2022 23:59

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Looking forward to Season 2 which premieres March 3rd 2022.

General Maximus 22-01-2022 15:28

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 

Pierre 22-01-2022 16:17

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by General Maximus (Post 36110667)

Lots to unpack from that.

Jaymoss 03-03-2022 18:10

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Excellent start to S2. Season preview at the ends looks awesome

Chris 04-03-2022 21:14

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Superb first episode. Lots of little Easter eggs. And some proper starfleet action at last. :D

Stephen 04-03-2022 23:17

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
I was very pleased at how good it was and all they've changed after much criticism over S1 in that it didn't really feel like star trek. They certainly went all out on fixing it just for the opening scene even.

SnoopZ 05-03-2022 00:09

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Really enjoyed it.

Chris 05-03-2022 09:18

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stephen (Post 36115675)
I was very pleased at how good it was and all they've changed after much criticism over S1 in that it didn't really feel like star trek. They certainly went all out on fixing it just for the opening scene even.

I wasn’t nearly as bothered as some that S1 didn’t feel like Star Trek. I was happy with the proposition that we were following the private adventures of a retired starfleet officer. The universe Star Trek depicts is vastly greater than starfleet and I enjoyed seeing it from a viewpoint the shows don’t often give us.

From the teasers I’ve seen, that first episode is about as much starfleet as we’re going to get in this season. From here on, Q has done something naughty, and Picard is going to find himself dealing with some very unfamiliar situations.

1701-e 05-03-2022 10:05

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36115430)
Excellent start to S2. Season preview at the ends looks awesome

Must have been only on paramount plus. Prime didn't have anything

Jaymoss 05-03-2022 11:48

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1701-e (Post 36115687)
Must have been only on paramount plus. Prime didn't have anything

It was found and downloaded by Sonarr hahaha

BenMcr 05-03-2022 17:35

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1701-e (Post 36115687)
Must have been only on paramount plus. Prime didn't have anything

Assume it's this that's been posted to the website
https://intl.startrek.com/videos/pre...ar-trek-picard

Jaymoss 05-03-2022 19:00

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
If he meant the season preview it was included on the file I got hold of. That site wont load due to my adblocker

Paul 05-03-2022 23:39

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Its in the copy I have as well.

Interesting start to Season 2.

General Maximus 06-03-2022 01:09

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
What a superb way to respect and honour the man. If the episodes weren't released weekly and the entire season had dropped in one go I would be staying up tonight and watching it.

Pierre 07-03-2022 11:31

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
A few observations.

Loved the way Q started out de-aged, just for a second or two.

Loved how the trip out through the solar system, riffed on the opening titles of TNG.

Was surprised to see the Excelsior, and it looked like the original Excelsior which would have made it a very old ship to still be in service!

I probably missed lots of other eggs, I'll have to go and fine them.

GrimUpNorth 07-03-2022 11:41

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
What made it better for me was I'd forgotten it was starting so fired up Plex to watch Discovery and there it was. Oh and thanks to Q they can go off and do what they want without worrying about changing history. Think it's going to be superb but also hope they manage to put history back to normal by the end of season 3!

Jaymoss 07-03-2022 12:50

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GrimUpNorth (Post 36115818)
What made it better for me was I'd forgotten it was starting so fired up Plex to watch Discovery and there it was. Oh and thanks to Q they can go off and do what they want without worrying about changing history. Think it's going to be superb but also hope they manage to put history back to normal by the end of season 3!

you subbing to someone for your plex? I run a plex server but just for family

GrimUpNorth 07-03-2022 14:33

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36115823)
you subbing to someone for your plex? I run a plex server but just for family

My own server, with nzbfinder.ws, Sonarr and SABnzdb.

Jaymoss 07-03-2022 14:56

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GrimUpNorth (Post 36115835)
My own server, with nzbfinder.ws, Sonarr and SABnzdb.

I use all them as well with Radarr, Tabula Rasa and NzbNoob as extra indexers

Pierre 25-03-2022 20:51

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
This week is woke week.

So many Hispanics being disappeared, Nasty government ICE agents channelling that NAZI spirit, a young Guinan telling Picard he has the power to change things as a white man, whilst a black woman such as herself ….not so much. We’re killing the planet…..

ST has always ran with story lines that reflected current issues or important issues, I know.

But I felt like I was being hit over the head with it in this episode. Maybe I’m being over sensitive.

Jaymoss 25-03-2022 21:00

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 36117504)
This week is woke week.

So many Hispanics being disappeared, Nasty government ICE agents channelling that NAZI spirit, a young Guinan telling Picard he has the power to change things as a white man, whilst a black woman such as herself ….not so much. We’re killing the planet…..

ST has always ran with story lines that reflected current issues or important issues, I know.

But I felt like I was being hit over the head with it in this episode. Maybe I’m being over sensitive.

Loved the Kirk R. Thatcher cameo though hahaha took me right back

General Maximus 25-03-2022 21:05

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 36117504)
This week is woke week.
But I felt like I was being hit over the head with it in this episode. Maybe I’m being over sensitive.

That's how i feel about Discovery every week. I loved the reference to Star Trek 4 though. It made me laugh.

Stephen 25-03-2022 21:14

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Can't say any of this wokeness has really stood out or felt in my face. Hadn't given it a second thought to be honest. It's stuff you hear and see most days so isn't unusual.

Pierre 25-03-2022 21:21

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by General Maximus (Post 36117507)
That's how i feel about Discovery every week. I loved the reference to Star Trek 4 though. It made me laugh.

It was funny, but how many people would have a ghetto blaster in 2024!


A pair of Beats Pods in his ears whilst looking at his iPhone wouldn’t have the same affect, I suppose!

Jaymoss 25-03-2022 21:32

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
ear pods would not be very punk would they haha

Paul 25-03-2022 21:52

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stephen (Post 36117509)
Can't say any of this wokeness has really stood out or felt in my face.

Oh it did, it was almost cringeworthy. :sleep:

---------- Post added at 21:52 ---------- Previous post was at 21:50 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaymoss (Post 36117505)
Loved the Kirk R. Thatcher cameo though hahaha took me right back

I didnt realise it was the same guy until seeing it mentioned somewhere. :)

General Maximus 26-03-2022 18:49

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36117517)
Oh it did, it was almost cringeworthy. :sleep:

I am surprised you have stayed so quiet over Discovery

pip08456 05-04-2022 20:55

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
1 Attachment(s)
Levar Burton, Michael Dorn, Johnathan Frakes, Gates McFadden, Marina Sirtis and Brent Spinner will be joining the cast of Star Trek: Picard for Season 3.

General Maximus 05-04-2022 21:05

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Fantastic. I had a feeling they were spreading the returning guests out because they have said several times that they didnt want it to be TNG 2.0 and any returns would have to be in keeping with the story. I was hoping they would get Geordie and Worf back for season 3. What would be beautiful, and make me cry, is if the closing scene in the final episode is all the characters together again for what I imagine will be the very last time ever.

Stephen 05-04-2022 21:17

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
I thought season 3 was filmed straight after 2?

Season 3 is also the last so should be a great send off for Picard.

General Maximus 05-04-2022 21:23

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stephen (Post 36118229)
I thought season 3 was filmed straight after 2?

Correct

Paul 05-04-2022 23:03

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Wasnt Brent Spiner in Season 1 ?

pip08456 05-04-2022 23:05

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stephen (Post 36118229)
I thought season 3 was filmed straight after 2?

Season 3 is also the last so should be a great send off for Picard.

Yes, but it was only today they announced who would be in it as guest stars. They'd kept it under wraps until now.

---------- Post added at 23:05 ---------- Previous post was at 23:05 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36118240)
Wasnt Brent Spiner in Season 1 ?

Briefly.

BenMcr 05-04-2022 23:08

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pip08456 (Post 36118242)
Briefly.

And twice. Several appearances as Data and a Soong

General Maximus 05-04-2022 23:12

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul (Post 36118240)
Wasnt Brent Spiner in Season 1 ?

As well as Riker and Troi

General Maximus 06-04-2022 10:10

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Get your tissues ready..........







Have you got them?






Paul 06-04-2022 11:56

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Well I guess that means he fixes the timeline in Season 2. :D

General Maximus 06-04-2022 14:10

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
What's made me curious is when they are planning to release it because it is the first time i have ever seen a series/season promoted half way through the previous season. I could understand them teasing us as soon as season 2 finished but we are only half way through. They have finished filming season 3 so it may be sooner than we think....

cimt 06-04-2022 14:26

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
It'll be next year. They also teasing Strange New Worlds S2 and we don't even have S1 yet.

Pierre 09-04-2022 10:02

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Help me out, is Picard an android or not?

Stephen 09-04-2022 10:18

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 36118594)
Help me out, is Picard an android or not?

His body is, but it behaves like a real body.

Jaymoss 09-04-2022 10:27

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 36118594)
Help me out, is Picard an android or not?

"Some transplants, how many"
"all of them"
And then the equipment went sparky sparky

General Maximus 09-04-2022 10:38

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 36118594)
Help me out, is Picard an android or not?

I was thinking the same thing

Chris 09-04-2022 10:55

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 36118594)
Help me out, is Picard an android or not?

His body is artificial but designed to mimic biological life as closely as possible. It started as a ‘golem’, a lifeless template which was then finished by reference to deep scans of the dying body it was to replace. Picard has had, more or less, a whole body transplant, as was alluded to in the dialogue this week.

Remember we had 7 complete seasons to learn exactly what Soong had achieved with Data, Lore and Juliana, and that was achieved through multiple episodes devoted to the topic. We’re never going to get quite that level of in-universe exposition in Picard.

General Maximus 15-04-2022 00:53

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
I was really hoping he was from the Relativity and had come back to help

Pierre 15-04-2022 20:42

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
That may well be the best hour of Star Trek I have ever watched. At first I thought, is that Dr Bashir? I recognised him but couldn’t place him, then obviously..that’s who he is! (actor wise).

Some call backs….l’m from Iowa, I only work in outer space…..for example.

Great stuff.

Stephen 15-04-2022 21:05

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
It was the guy that played Gaius Baltar in Battlestar Galactica.

Jaymoss 15-04-2022 21:25

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stephen (Post 36119253)
It was the guy that played Gaius Baltar in Battlestar Galactica.

James Callis

Paul 16-04-2022 02:37

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 36119251)
At first I thought, is that Dr Bashir? I recognised him but couldn’t place him

Baltar :D

Chris 16-04-2022 10:49

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Also Bridget Jones’ best (gay) friend Tom, a role he camped up to the moon and back and clearly had far too much fun with :D

It’s good to have an actor of note involved when you’re canonising the backstory of legends like Picard - I’m glad that he gets to be Picard snr. even if we never get to see him on screen again.

cimt 17-04-2022 03:27

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
I feel like we will see him again. It was mentioned that there is more to his backstory.

GrimUpNorth 21-04-2022 19:55

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Will stick with it, but found myself getting a bit bored during today's episode.

General Maximus 21-04-2022 20:40

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
We are nearly at the end anyways

GrimUpNorth 21-04-2022 20:45

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by General Maximus (Post 36119754)
We are nearly at the end anyways

Don't think I'm a fan of the story running through the entire series, enjoyed it when it was wrapped up in an episode or at most continued from the last episode of one series to the first of the next. I liked how you could dip in and out without worrying about what happened last week. I'm sure I'm not alone!

General Maximus 21-04-2022 20:58

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
I dont mind serialised stories because they give you chance to really sink your teeth into something. When they are done well they are fantastic (e.g. The Expanse and Reacher) but the problem i have noticed recently with streaming services is that somebody decides they want an 8 episode season, thinks of a start and a finish and then they have to work out how they fill the middle. Like you said, i think some of these stories could be put into 3 or 4 good episodes but instead they are stretched out. The Book of Boba Fett is a perfect example of this. I would rather them tell a quality story for as long (or as short) as it needs to be and then move onto the next story which naturally follows on and progresses the overall story arch.

Pierre 29-04-2022 19:34

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
What an hour of quintessential Star Trek, that was.

alanbjames 29-04-2022 19:56

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
I just cant get into this second series it seems to be all over the place to much happening at once.

Stephen 29-04-2022 20:39

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
They've left a lot to fix and sort out for the last episode next week. So much will be brushed over quickly. Been mostly filler and wasted time.

alanbjames 29-04-2022 21:04

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
I'm just hoping that the 3rd and final season will be better than this.

Stephen 29-04-2022 21:18

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Well it's got all the TNG cast so that's 1 thing but it was written and filmed along with this season so who knows.

General Maximus 29-04-2022 21:52

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stephen (Post 36120539)
Well it's got all the TNG cast

that doesn't mean anything. I can't even begin to describe how much of a missed opportunity I think it has been to not have had more of Guinan/Whoopi Goldberg in this season. The story was literally screaming out for her and would have been a perfect excuse for her to spend some quality time with Picard and have a truly meaningful deep story arc. Instead we get all the drivel from the new wannabes. They (the writers and producers) know that if they bring all the TNG cast back early in season 3 and keep them, nobody will give two shits about the new cast they can happily retire to the background. I will go so far as to say that if any of them came into a scene and had dialogue that it would be met with fury because they will be taking away precious time from the TNG cast. In a perfect world hopefully there is an accident when they try to fix the timeline next week and the new cast get erased. It would be amazing if we can start season 3 off with a clean slate, the TNG cast and go out with a bang.

They have done their quirky story and cast changes for novelty, now it is time to bring it home and finish how it started.

Stephen 29-04-2022 22:05

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Wwll the new cast won't be erased. I think it will be a last hurrah for the TNG cast and they'll go on one last adventure together to do something 'important'

This season could have been great but they wasted too many episodes on things that should have taken 10 mins.

They have too much to resolve in a single episode. That it will be rushed and meaningless. Q being unwell has been totally forgotten about and to me was the main reason for the time travel and setup.

General Maximus 29-04-2022 22:21

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Exactly, this season could have been fantastic just dealing with Q and Guinan with a side of Data but instead we had to have all the other nonsense.

It baffles me how we can see it but the muppets in the writers room can't.

Stephen 29-04-2022 22:34

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Not only that but the amount of time they wasted on Picards mother and the flashbacks is ridiculous. Which also ignores TNG in that his mother was seen as an old woman, also where was Picards brother in all of those flashbacks? Did they forget about him?

General Maximus 29-04-2022 22:57

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
I am glad to see your realism factor is alive and well

https://www.cableforum.uk/images/local/2022/04/5.gif


I have tried to explain it a thousand times without any luck and this is what it is all about. Does what we are seeing and being told make sense within the confines and parameters of the established universe and what (if any) we already know.

Stephen 29-04-2022 23:56

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
There is no realism factor for me. But simply put there are decades of Trek history and lore that's just being ignored. Ship and tech designs that are being changed and replaced. It's just bad writing.

Chris 29-04-2022 23:56

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
I can’t even. Why do you even bother watching it?

This show’s interest in psychology is entirely consistent with TNG. Entire episodes were devoted to Data’s dream state (cellular peptide cake, anyone? It has sugar frosting), Riker’s brainwashing (or was it a play he was rehearsing for in 10-Forward?) and Picard’s will-he-won’t-he-break-under-torture (THERE ARE FIVE LIGHTS). The show’s entire musical score is built out from an episode that dealt with a computer-induced dream state.

Guys, much as I love chewing over sci fi with you all, I am deeply thankful you’re not allowed anywhere near the writers room. With the greatest of respect to you, if you had written this show it would have looked like the repetitive, one-trick fanwank that litters YouTube rather than a credible continuation of the franchise.

Stephen 30-04-2022 00:13

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
I simply disagree with that. I love every iteration of Trek so much and have seen enough to know what makes a good episode or story.

However writers now are focusing too much on entire season arcs of 8-10 episodes. When in the past this kind of story could be done in a 2 part story.

They often feel dragged out and filled with so much fluff just to make the story track to a full season. Rather than the serialised single self contained stories that we used to tune in for.

You could honestly watch episode 1 and 2 then watch the last one and you wouldn't have missed much.

Where as any old Trek season you could watch any episode and know that that story would be done by the end of the episode.this is not treally a credible continuation of the show at all. Its trying too hard to be fanwanky and getting it so so wrong.

Chris 30-04-2022 00:34

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Serialisation is just what happens now on streaming services. It doesn’t matter which universe we’re in and whether it’s a new one or a well established one like Star Trek. You’re just not going to get a season full of stand-alone episodes. The nearest you might get in the forthcoming SNW series is an arc that is nearer the foreground in some episodes than others, and then only if they’re being uber-traditional and resisting the logic of streaming services which strongly favours binge-watching (even shows that are premiered weekly, because they remain on the service indefinitely afterwards).

The vast majority of TNG episodes have an ‘A’ plot and a ‘B’ plot. Even the stories that are remembered for being action-heavy are actually quite well diluted with introspective sub-plotting (so in “The Enemy” for example, Picard facing off against Tomalak in orbit over Galorndon Core is balanced by Geordi riffing off Enemy Mine on the surface with a crashed Romulan scout). The touchy-feely introspection in Picard really is nothing new. Nor is variation in the pace of the storytelling.

It seems you don’t know what “fanwank” means - by definition it isn’t anything new or challenging. It’s mindless porn, designed to appeal to the basic cravings of unimaginative fans who demand the same old egg and chips week in, week out. It’s exactly why fan-made episodes of TOS are almost universally awful (with the possible exception of Star Trek Continues, which manages to steer just far enough away from tribute act territory, some of the time at least, to make it possible to simply enjoy the detailed recreation of the look and feel of the original despite the derivative plots and the not-in-game-footage acting). Whether you like Picard or not, it absolutely isn’t fanwank in any shape or form.

General Maximus 30-04-2022 00:41

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stephen (Post 36120569)
However writers now are focusing too much on entire season arcs of 8-10 episodes. When in the past this kind of story could be done in a 2 part story

exactly, and that is my problem with stuff like Boba Fett. Instead of saying "we need to tell this story/adventure/part of his life and it needs to take 3 episodes" and then move onto the next chapter/natural story progression, they take one little thread and needlessly pad it out to (I am not going to say a season because 10 episodes isn't a season) 8-10 episodes, finding rubbish to pad it out rather than doing a quality few episodes and focusing on a new story.

Working my way through Dial the Gate over the last couple of months has really made me appreciate how blessed we were with Stargate and how rare the writing was. Somebody needs to make a one-off documentary for the next Star Wars/Star Trek/Marvel season and have two rooms of writers with cameras in recording everything. One room with the normal peeps in, showing their thought process and the drivel they come up with and a second room with a proper team of skilled writers in from either something like Stargate or DS9, see what they come up with story wise and how it differs in richness and episodic length. There is a clear class divide in old school Star Trek and the creative team behind it and the new stuff and it isn't going to get any better. Every time I see Alex Kurtzman and Akiva Goldsman attached to something I cringe. If you watch the DS9 documentary What We Left Behind you will see what proper writing is all about.



Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36120572)
It seems you don’t know what “fanwank” means - by definition it isn’t anything new or challenging. It’s mindless porn, designed to appeal to the basic cravings of unimaginative fans who demand the same old egg and chips week in, week out. It’s exactly why fan-made episodes of TOS are almost universally awful (with the possible exception of Star Trek Continues, which manages to steer just far enough away from tribute act territory, some of the time at least). Whether you like Picard or not, it absolutely isn’t fanwank in any shape or form.

so you are happy with what they have done with Q this season and don't feel they could have made more of it or the season would have been better if they had spent more time with him and gone into his story a bit more and cut out something else? Like Stephen said above, there is too much to cram into the finale next week. Why is Q dying, why did he send everyone back in time and what did he hope to gain from it? That is an episode in itself at the minimum without wrapping all the other characters up and dealing with this Europa space shuttle launch. They ruin the series by dwelling on naff and trivia and not spending the time on the characters that they need to. It just baffles me. They introduce these potentially rich story lines which would go down a treat and then just throw them to one side ignoring them, laughing at the audience and slapping them in the face.

Stephen 30-04-2022 01:11

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
I think it's the fact the claim to have writers who love Trek and know everything, and yet they get historical things that happened in the show wrong or 8gnore what they want to invent new things for 3xisitng characters etc. They did the same thing in Discovery by inventing a sister for Spock and totally ruining the history and design of the klingons it's just the simple things seem so hard for them.

General Maximus 30-04-2022 01:25

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Exactly

https://www.cableforum.uk/images/local/2022/04/6.gif



All the points you have made this evening is what my realism factor is all about. You can call it whatever you want but we are on the same wavelength.

https://www.cableforum.uk/images/local/2022/04/7.gif

Pierre 30-04-2022 09:00

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by General Maximus (Post 36120573)
Why is Q dying, why did he send everyone back in time and what did he hope to gain from it? That is an episode in itself at the minimum.

There is still an episode left…………..

---------- Post added at 09:00 ---------- Previous post was at 08:58 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stephen (Post 36120557)
Not only that but the amount of time they wasted on Picards mother and the flashbacks is ridiculous. Which also ignores TNG in that his mother was seen as an old woman, also where was Picards brother in all of those flashbacks? Did they forget about him?

There’s been that many timelines and resets, who knows, or cares.

Maggy 30-04-2022 09:50

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 36120589)
There is still an episode left…………..

---------- Post added at 09:00 ---------- Previous post was at 08:58 ----------



There’s been that many timelines and resets, who knows, or cares.


General Maximus 30-04-2022 12:02

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by General Maximus (Post 36120573)
Like Stephen said above, there is too much to cram into the finale next week.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 36120589)
There is still an episode left…………..

https://www.cableforum.uk/images/local/2022/04/9.gif

Paul 30-04-2022 18:35

Re: Star Trek: Picard
 
There is still a Season left ;)


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 14:34.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.